The Technological Republic
In April 2026, the media reported about a manifesto which Alex Karp, one of the founders of the software company Palantir, had posted to X. Many of these reports were negative and considered the manifesto a threat. When I learned that the manifesto was essentially a summary of a book published a year ago, The Technological Republic, I decided to get hold of the book to learn the message Karp wants to spread.
The central message of this book is that the software industry should
support the state and be closely aligned with the government to combine
"a pursuit of innovation with the objectives of the nation". The authors
speak of a "national plan" to which every citizen should be committed,
which should involve research and development in space travel, medicine,
and military. The military is especially important. The adversaries of
the West, most notably China and Russia, will invest in upgrading their
military with artificial intelligence, the authors are sure. Western
politicians have often underestimated authoritarian regimes. They
believed, following Francis Fukuyama, that liberal democracy was the
ultimate end-state of political development. But Russia and China have
still not become liberal democracies. Therefore the West must prepare
for war fought using artificial intelligence technology. Palantir is one
of the companies that are providing equipment for it. In contrast to
that, most Silicon Valley entrepreneurs currently focus on consumer
goods, social media, chat and photo-sharing apps, while refusing to
cooperate with the government and the army. This attitude needs to be
changed, the authors state. As Walter Isaacson wrote in his review of
this book: "This book is a rallying cry, as we enter the age of
artificial intelligence, for a return to the World War II era of
cooperation between the technology industry and government in order to
pursue innovation that will advance our national welfare and democratic
goals."
Much of the second part of the
book reads like a continuation of Allan Bloom's 1987 book "The Closing
of the American Mind". The authors complain that the current leaders of
the United States lack a national vision. They call for a kind of civic
religion to be founded. One chapter of this part deals with the
abolition of Western civilization classes at American universities. In
this context the authors praise the increasing number of computer
science graduates but express the critical view that "we need engineers
who are engaged with and curious about the world, the movement of
history and its contradictions, not merely skilled at programming".
The
third part mainly revolves around the virtues of the authors' company,
Palantir, and its cultural embedding in Silicon Valley, such as
resistance to conformity. The authors illustrate their arguments by
references to some classical scientific experiments such as the
well-known Milgram experiment.
The vision of the technological republic is the theme of the final part, in which the authors stress that the USA need a national plan and a national identity.
I think that the message of the book is clear: It calls entrepreneurs and politicians to action, to concert their efforts. In this respect it is interesting that Karp, according to Wikipedia, is actually opposed to President Trump. He calls himself a "socialist" and says that he supported Hillary Clinton. Indeed the political program of this book might be called statist if not even nationalist. While I agree that medicine is a good field to develop software for, it is just one of several areas the strengthening of which the authors suggest, the main one being the military. Of course it makes sense to use artificial intelligence in the American military if America's adversaries will do the same. What's controversial, however, is that military equipment can also be used for aggressive purposes.
Claus D. Volko
Comments
Post a Comment